I have my desktop computer back, two trips to Tucson and almost $700 later.
I'm a confirmed Mac guy from way back. The first computer I bought after my old Kaypro II was an Apple, and I have been a faithful user/customer ever since. I can't quite imagine ever putting myself through what PC users do, and like to support good, reliable, user-friendly technology whenever possible, even though there's a premium--the Mac tax--on it.
But, in my continuing efforts to warn the world about bad customer service, I do have a complaint about the Apple store.
As mentioned previously, this computer needed a new logic board. The computer is only 4 years old, and that's the third one it's had. For a usually reliable product, that's not a great track record.
When I suggested as much at the store, though, the "genius" at the genius bar told me that people usually buy new computers before then, so it's not an issue.
That upset me. I still have a first generation iMac that runs fine--you can't get software for it, of course, and the software it does have is outdated, but it runs. It has never had a logic board replaced. If I was using a PC, I'd expect to replace it every few years. But I pay more for Macs specifically because I expect them to be reliable machines, easily upgraded, that I won't have to keep replacing. Telling me that I should expect to have to spend as much to fix the Mac as some PCs cost new because I should just be replacing them on a cheap PC schedule eliminates the main reason for buying Mac. If that's the case, then why haven't I been buying cheap PCs all along?
I'm not ready to make the switch yet. For one thing, the environmental costs of junking old computers every couple of years are huge. For another, I like the Mac user experience in general, I'm used to it and to my software, and I have a lot invested in it.
But meeting another "genius" or two with that sort of attitude will sour me in a hurry. Has Apple decided that it's real business is in phones and music players? Have they given up on the idea of outdoing PCs in reliability and quality? Or was this guy a fluke, maybe someone brought in from Circuit City or Best Buy who doesn't understand Mac users yet.
Either way, the next time this thing needs a new logic board, I have a feeling it'll be headed for the scrap heap instead of being fixed. And for the first time, I'll have to give serious consideration to replacing it with a PC. Unless Steve Jobs does something to bring me back into the fold...